NERA Expert Analysis a Key Factor in Favorable ERISA Case Decision for State Street Motion to Dismiss Granted

13 April 2010

New York -- Dr. Robert Mackay, Senior Vice President and Chair of NERA Economic Consulting's Global Securities and Finance Practice, provided expert analysis on behalf of State Street Corporation in a recent case involving alleged violations of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). This case is noteworthy as it demonstrates that unrealized losses caused by mark-to-market values being below par do not automatically lead to investor injury.

In the case, Fishman Haygood Phelps Walmsley Willis & Swanson, LLP v. State Street Corporation, et al, plaintiffs sought class action status, alleging that State Street breached its duties of prudence and loyalty by engaging in a securities lending program as part of their administration of a trust fund in which plaintiffs were investors. Plaintiffs alleged that State Street reinvested cash collateral in "long-term, high-risk instruments" leading to realized and unrealized losses, rather than making more "prudent" investments in money market funds or Treasury securities. In response, State Street through its counsel, Wilmer Hale, filed a motion to dismiss on the grounds that the plaintiffs lacked Article III standing under ERISA, as they had not suffered any actual injury.

In a decision announced on 25 March 2010, United States District Court Judge Patti Saris allowed the motion to dismiss filed by the Wilmer Hale team led by Ms. Lori Martin , citing at length Dr. Mackay's testimony and expert analysis for the defense affirming the lack of plaintiff injury and breach of fiduciary duties.

As the Court's decision noted, Dr. Mackay demonstrated that the plaintiffs had not suffered a direct injury from unrealized losses and that any future injury was not imminent. Even though the mark-to-market value of cash collateral pool units was below par, the plaintiffs and the trust they were invested in had continued to transact cash collateral pool units at par. In addition, the plaintiffs did not face any restriction on redemptions, there was sufficient liquidity in cash collateral pools and none of the securities held by the cash collateral pools had defaulted or was impaired. As such, the plaintiffs' unrealized losses did not establish injury for the purposes of Article III.

The Court further noted that Dr. Mackay "show(ed) that the allegedly imprudent investments made by State Street outperformed hypothetical investments in 'short-term Treasuries' and money market funds at all times ... " during the complaint period even after consideration of realized losses in cash collateral pools. These hypothetical investments had been put forward by the plaintiffs and their expert as "prudent" investments for purposes of measurement of damages. Hence, the Court held that, "under the measure of damages defined by the First Circuit in Evans, the plaintiff has not established injury-in-fact for the purposes of Article III standing."

The US District Court's decision can be read here.

About NERA

NERA Economic Consulting ( is a global firm of experts dedicated to applying economic, finance, and quantitative principles to complex business and legal challenges. For over half a century, NERA's economists have been creating strategies, studies, reports, expert testimony, and policy recommendations for government authorities and the world's leading law firms and corporations. We bring academic rigor, objectivity, and real world industry experience to bear on issues arising from competition, regulation, public policy, strategy, finance, and litigation.

NERA's clients value our ability to apply and communicate state-of-the-art approaches clearly and convincingly, our commitment to deliver unbiased findings, and our reputation for quality and independence. Our clients rely on the integrity and skills of our unparalleled team of economists and other experts backed by the resources and reliability of one of the world's largest economic consultancies. With its main office in New York City, NERA serves clients from more than 25 offices across North America, Europe, and Asia Pacific.