There is no question artificial intelligence is changing how professional services firms will do their work. Those changes are in motion, and while we don’t know exactly what changes will stick, there is another fundamental question we need to be thinking about: Where will the next generation of partners and experts come from?
Professional services firms build senior talent in two ways: organic growth and lateral hiring. With the organic growth model, firms develop people from within—by hiring talented professionals early in their careers, giving them increasingly challenging work, surrounding them with experienced colleagues, and allowing years of apprenticeship to turn knowledge and judgment into expertise. With lateral hiring, firms recruit established talent from outside the organization—by bringing in partners or experts with proven experience, client relationships, and, in some cases, an existing team and book of business.
Many firms do both.
The strategic question is not which model is right but how much emphasis should be placed on each and how AI changes the economics of that balance.
Changes to the Traditional Path to Partnership
Organic growth has always taken time. You cannot develop an experienced economist, lawyer, or consultant overnight. An economist starting her career might spend years organizing and analyzing data, reviewing documents, developing econometric models, helping prepare reports, and observing senior experts as they work with clients and counsel before she becomes a leading expert in her field. Similarly, a lawyer starting his career might spend years doing legal research, drafting discovery requests and motions, and observing more senior lawyers and partners work with clients, take and defend depositions, negotiate settlements, and take cases to trial before he becomes the lawyer clients turn to for their toughest issues.
Some of the tasks one does in the early years may look routine when viewed in isolation, but collectively, they add up and become the “reps” through which young professionals learn their craft.
AI, however, is changing the nature of those reps and how many a young person gets.
If an AI tool can complete in minutes an analysis that once required hours, that is a significant productivity gain. Firms should embrace that gain and think carefully about how to reinvest it. But the gain comes at the cost of a lost rep.
Real skill development is not just a matter of time or billable hours, of course, and I’m not suggesting that consulting firms and law firms continue to bill for hours that are no longer needed just to train their next generation. What I am saying is that real partner development will no longer be the natural byproduct of the billable hours workflow. Indeed, in a recent article, McKinsey hit the nail on the head, noting that remote work has already placed pressure on traditional apprenticeship models and that AI may compound the challenge. As they described it, “relying on AI to complete work can reduce opportunities to develop skills unless users actively engage with and verify its output. Without proactive interventions to replace this source of experience, future leaders might not get the reps that build judgment and the depth of understanding that they need.”
“Proactive intervention,” though, means more senior time and attention, which leads to the business and strategic question that professional services firms will have to tackle: Why make that investment at all? Why not let another firm train the next generation of partners and recruit them once they are established?
Baseball’s Farm System
As I thought about this question, I found myself thinking about baseball.
A professional baseball team can invest years developing young players in its farm system only to see some of its best talent eventually leave for a team with more money or negotiating leverage. From the perspective of the acquiring team, however, signing a proven player can look like an attractive strategy. Rather than bear the cost and uncertainty of developing talent, the team can invest once it knows the player can perform.
Professional services firms face similar issues.
Developing a future major league partner or senior expert takes years. Not everyone will succeed. Some of the people that a firm trains will leave before the investment pays off. And if AI requires professional development to be more deliberate and time-intensive, developing that future partner could be even more costly.
Lateral recruiting avoids some of the costs and risks of internal partner development, and it can be an excellent strategy if a firm needs a specialized capability quickly, wants to enter a new market, faces upcoming retirements, or sees an opportunity built around a particular rainmaker or expert.
But lateral hiring also comes with risks. If every firm decides that developing people is too expensive and that it would rather recruit established talent, there is a problem. Where will tomorrow’s experienced partners come from if firms aren’t giving them the reps and mentoring they need today?
On top of that, if the supply of partner-level talent shrinks, firms that rely heavily on recruiting laterals are likely to face a smaller pool of candidates, greater competition, and increasingly expensive premiums for the people everyone wants.
This is probably why the major league teams all have their own farm system. Because it still pays to have your own pipeline of internal talent.
For the same reason, internal partner development at professional services firms will continue to be strategically important in the age of AI.
What Might Partner Development Look Like?
If the next generation of talent has fewer reps, firms will have to commit more senior time to individual partner development. But firms are going to have to do more than that. While baseball’s farm system operates in a different market and institutional environment, there are things that ball teams do that could apply to professional services. I say that because, like professional services, baseball teams deliver a service that is inseparable from the individual players on the team. Moreover, while fans want their teams to be stocked with top talent, they are also counting on the players to work together as a team.
It’s the same for professional services firms. Clients clearly want to work with a professional services firm that has the underlying professional talent, but they also want that firm to work together as a team. This has to be the case. When clients retain an economic consulting firm, for example, they aren’t simply looking for a star expert. They are looking for a team that can handle all aspects of the economic analysis. When clients retain a law firm, they aren’t simply looking for advice and a set of legal briefs and arguments. They are looking for a team that can develop the full legal strategy and body of evidence that is needed, which means they need a law firm that can execute as a team.
If you agree with that, then partner development has to be more than just an exercise in giving the next generation the reps they need to gain the expertise and judgment to be firm leaders. Partner development also has to be about team development.
This is, by the way, what the best-run farm systems in baseball do. They inculcate in their players how they want the team to play, prepare, practice, communicate, and work together so that when the players and coaches get to the major leagues, they are ready.
Thus, for professional services firms, developing partners internally is not simply an investment in an individual. It is an investment in the team, the firm, and, ultimately, the future of the franchise. When people develop together, they learn how their colleagues think and work. They build trust. They develop relationships across offices and areas of expertise. They learn when to involve another expert whose experience can help solve a client’s problem. Over time, those relationships become the team through which the firm serves larger and more complicated client needs.
The Payoff from Investing in Your Farm Team
Investing in your people is a competitive move because you are building your future partner group, which is a scarce and valuable asset that neither AI nor lateral recruitment can easily replace. This investment, not just in individuals but in the firm’s future, is where the real payoff has to be.
If you think of partner development as a firm-level investment—for example, one that involves fostering a cohesive culture that attracts and retains the talent you want—then not only are you developing your next generation of leaders, you are also giving them a reason to stay. And in a world in which partner-level talent is scarce and lateral hiring is a constant threat, investing in a team that shares the same culture, goals, and playbook has to be an investment worth making.
Economists call this a firm-specific investment—as opposed to a general investment in player skills that players take with them if they were to leave—and economics teaches us that in markets in which it is easier to hire laterally, the incentive to offer general training falls since competitors can free-ride on that training. In these markets, firms should instead lean toward making firm-specific investments, such as those that build the cohesive culture and working relationships that will help the team execute for their clients, which benefit the team and the individuals on the team.
Retaining your top talent will also help with client retention, particularly with respect to clients that are looking for a firm that can offer a full range of services. For a law firm, this is clearly important given that clients typically need a broad range of services from firms that really know and understand their business. The same is true for economic consulting firms.
Partner Development with Purpose
Partner development takes time, so the decisions firms make now about people will determine who their senior partners, experts, and rainmakers will be years from now; the culture of the firm that will give those partners a good reason to stick around; and the kinds of relationships they have with their clients. Major leaguers do not grow on trees. And neither do professional economists, top lawyers, trusted advisers, trial experts, leaders, or the next rainmaker expert. That is why I believe the partner-development question becomes even more strategically important as AI becomes more capable.
The strongest firms will develop their partners internally and look for lateral hires; there is no reason to pick one strategy. The right mix, however, will differ from firm to firm. And when it comes to partner development, there needs to be purpose because the more important question is whether you can construct a partner development plan that will pay off. A partner development plan that makes economic sense is therefore a plan that builds not only your future partner base but also the team and culture that will give the people you invest in a reason to stay.